Edward Snowden 0 Report post Posted September 9, 2019 The other day my buddy caught two trout that swallowed his fly. (wooly bigger) He tried to remove the hook from the first, but it started bleeding and he cut the tippet. Should he have gone ahead and dispatched the fish? The second he just cut the trout free. Is this a death sentence for a trout? I would really like to know what is the best way to handle this situation. Thank you in advance. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
bullhead 0 Report post Posted September 9, 2019 It has been said said to cut the line and the hook will eventually dissolve. I am not sure that this is entirely correct. Sure some fish will die especially if the gills are involved. My experience when hooking bass with poppers is they can take the hook deep so I always pinch down the barbs. Very easy to back out with minimal damage to the fish. Bullhead Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Philly 0 Report post Posted September 9, 2019 I've caught fish that still had the hook from a previous catching in their throat or gullet. Best thing would be to debarb the hook or use a barbless hook. They're much easier to remove. As far as dispatching the fish, if you're going to eat it, then I don't see a problem. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Steeldrifter 0 Report post Posted September 9, 2019 Hooked in stomach usually they will survive long as its not totally blocking them from swallowing food. Hooked in gill is usually best to dispatch them and eat or give to someone to eat. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
mikechell 0 Report post Posted September 9, 2019 This trick works with bass, and larger hooks. Open the fish's mouth as much as you can without hurting the fish. Using needle nose pliers or hemostats, reach through the gap between the inner most gill and the body of the fish on the side the hook is "aimed". Grab the line or the eye of the hook and pull it back through the gap. This will turn the hook. Reach in through the mouth, grab the bend of the hook and remove it. It's worked with every bass that's been gut hooked. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
vicente 0 Report post Posted September 9, 2019 I usually use a stick with a notch on the end to remove hooks that are in really deep. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
tjm 0 Report post Posted September 9, 2019 Last study I read said they (several years ago now & iirc in NJ) survive best if when you cut the leader you leave about a foot of leader hanging out of the mouth- this supposedly will keep the hook from blocking the food in take. in that study the cut short as possible leaders led to mortality, supposedly from the hook blocking the gullet . I believe a Canadian study on pike about the same time indicated that hooks don't dissolve readily but that fish often rid them selves of the hook within 48 hours. I've read several places that Mikechell's method works well, on bass. My hooks are all barbless or bent down barbs because I believe they penetrate better, and they usually come out pretty easy, but if I can't easily reach it with forceps, I have cut the tippet long as suggested in that study- however if a fish is bleeding I don't have much hope that it will survive, if a legal fish I'd sure dispatch and eat. If a no keeper you have no choice but to release it, "unharmed". I have also read anecdotes of fish caught with hook and some leader hanging from the vent, as if passed through the digestive system. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Steeldrifter 0 Report post Posted September 9, 2019 I have also read anecdotes of fish caught with hook and some leader hanging from the vent, as if passed through the digestive system. Yep it happens. I've actually caught a few bass like that over the years. Really weird thing to see Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
SilverCreek 0 Report post Posted September 9, 2019 Ketchum hook remover http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xptYPB7KCos Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Mark Knapp 0 Report post Posted September 9, 2019 I caught and kept a 19 inch rainbow one time that had a line hanging from his vent. When I cleaned him the hook was in his stomach. The hook wasn't corroded very much but the wound was healed around the hook. The fish appeared to be healthy in every way. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
fshng2 0 Report post Posted September 9, 2019 Matt Allen Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
flytire 0 Report post Posted September 9, 2019 I would really like to know what is the best way to handle this situation. coat with cornmeal and pan fry in garlic butter Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Kevin6707 0 Report post Posted November 15, 2020 This happened to me today. I'm new at fishing. I moved from a city to the way out there sticks. The only thing to do is fish. I felt really bad because I have no clue what to do. My first hook was a brook trout and he took my line, couldn't tell how he was hooked since he never made it out the water, only the surface. The second hook was a beautiful rainbow trout and he swallowed my hook! All I could do was cut the line. When I put him back in the water I felt horrible. I just want to fish for sport with my daughter. I don't eat fish. I've never liked the taste. I'm reading this forum and seeing great ideas that I'll try moving forward. I'm going barbless and I'll use forceps. I just want to make memories with my baby girl and not stress the fish anymore than I caught it. I'm glad I found this forum. Thanks guys. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
vicrider 0 Report post Posted November 15, 2020 If you're using bait Kevin, learn to set the hook at the first instant you feel life. If you miss a few fish and you're fishing for fun it shouldn't hurt but most times by the time you feel fish they have the bait in their mouth and you don't want to let them chew and swallow. Check with any of your neighbors and see if they'd like a fish or two if you do hook a fish so you don't think it'll make it. The worst hooking is damaging gills. Most other places a fish from cold water will survive, even if bleeding a little. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Jaydub 0 Report post Posted November 15, 2020 My $.02 Reaching through the gills may work with Bass, but Trout have much smaller gills and mouths. I don't think I would try that. If legal, I would keep any fish that is bleeding or hooked through the gills or eye. If it's just deeply hooked and you can't get it out quickly, cut the leader and get the fish back in the water. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites