flyfishing99 0 Report post Posted November 17, 2010 Hi, I was told that I only use this forum to spam about my blogspot, but that really isn't the case. Wonder what you think of my method of spinning deer hair to form a hackle. This fly, if I get a photo up, is to imitate an emerged flav. Also trying to post a photo of it floating in a tupperware dish. Note the change in color of the dubbing once wet. Granted, the color on my pictures is not 100% due to lighting, but it is worth remembering that wet dubbing tends to "darken" when wet. Please let me know what you think. Thanks Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
whatfly 0 Report post Posted November 17, 2010 By "my method" I assume you mean "my attempt" because the technique has been around for some time (I've no idea who first used it). Nice tie. I'm curious why you think you should bother with this on smaller flies. Either hackle or a comparadun-style wing would work just as well, IMHO (and in the Comparadun's case, perhaps even better). On larger patterns, I can see where this method might be more useful, but I only rarely tie dries larger than #14, so it has not been an approached I've ever explored. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
flyfishing99 0 Report post Posted November 17, 2010 By "my method" I assume you mean "my attempt" because the technique has been around for some time (I've no idea who first used it). Nice tie. I'm curious why you think you should bother with this on smaller flies. Either hackle or a comparadun-style wing would work just as well, IMHO (and in the Comparadun's case, perhaps even better). On larger patterns, I can see where this method might be more useful, but I only rarely tie dries larger than #14, so it has not been an approached I've ever explored. Hadn't seen it elsewhere. Where might I see others?? The reason I think it is worthwhile is because you can adjust such "made" hackle any size by just placing the deer hair "shorter" in the dubbing loop. If you are tying while on a fishing trip you don't need to take a number of sized hackle with you. I do like the comparaduns as well. Try these for variety!!!! Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
flyfishing99 0 Report post Posted November 17, 2010 By "my method" I assume you mean "my attempt" because the technique has been around for some time (I've no idea who first used it). Nice tie. I'm curious why you think you should bother with this on smaller flies. Either hackle or a comparadun-style wing would work just as well, IMHO (and in the Comparadun's case, perhaps even better). On larger patterns, I can see where this method might be more useful, but I only rarely tie dries larger than #14, so it has not been an approached I've ever explored. Hadn't seen it elsewhere. Where might I see others?? The reason I think it is worthwhile is because you can adjust such "made" hackle any size by just placing the deer hair "shorter" in the dubbing loop. If you are tying while on a fishing trip you don't need to take a number of sized hackle with you. I do like the comparaduns as well. Try these for variety!!!! This is a photo by Hans Weilenmann. It shows one of these first hackled with spun deer hair and then with spun cdc fibers. I dressed it sort of swept back. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
halcyon 0 Report post Posted November 17, 2010 This book dealing solely with Hair Hackle Techniques was published in 2001 and explains that the making and use of hair hackle is very old. Hair-Hackle Tying Techniques & Fly Patterns, by Gordon Mackenzie http://www.amatobooks.com/mm5/merchant.mvc...;Category_Code= Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
flyfishing99 0 Report post Posted November 17, 2010 This book dealing solely with Hair Hackle Techniques was published in 2001 and explains that the making and use of hair hackle is very old. Hair-Hackle Tying Techniques & Fly Patterns, by Gordon Mackenzie http://www.amatobooks.com/mm5/merchant.mvc...;Category_Code= Thanks. Do you happen to know a site that shows photos of the technique on dry flies? Would appreciate it Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Hans Weilenmann 0 Report post Posted November 17, 2010 Hadn't seen it elsewhere. Where might I see others?? Try here for a set of all-hair flies tied by Sven Ostermann, which I added to Flytier's Page in 2001: http://www.danica.com/flytier/sostermann/sostermann.htm A sample: Cheers, Hans W Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
MarianC 0 Report post Posted November 17, 2010 Have been using this metod for klinkhammer variant. The deer hair makes a good impresion of legs, by the simple fact that is more unequal after you spinn it on a dubbing loop Have to put a photo , that makes more than 1000 words Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Hans Weilenmann 0 Report post Posted November 17, 2010 Have been using this metod for klinkhammer variant. The deer hair makes a good impresion of legs, by the simple fact that is more unequal after you spin it on a dubbing loop Have to put a photo , that makes more than 1000 words MarianC, A little like this? I used squirrel hair in this pattern, but the effect is similar to deer hair. The Hair Witch Project Cheers, Hans W Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest Report post Posted November 17, 2010 Yeah this technique is fairly well known, Marc Petitjean even produces his Magic Tools to help in the process. His site has some very good videos of how to use the tool which gives a great step by step of exactly how to do it. He's using to tie a caddis wing in the video but you could easily tie a conventional hackle wing the exact same manner. Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
MarianC 0 Report post Posted November 17, 2010 Have been using this metod for klinkhammer variant. The deer hair makes a good impresion of legs, by the simple fact that is more unequal after you spin it on a dubbing loop Have to put a photo , that makes more than 1000 words MarianC, A little like this? I used squirrel hair in this pattern, but the effect is similar to deer hair. The Hair Witch Project Cheers, Hans W yeap With dear hair, you have some advantages: it is hollow fiber, so it floats better if you let the fiber just a littel bit longer, the flie, will seat deeper in the water surface. Hans, try this, make a klinkhammer, and make the hackle with deer hair, after you finish it put it in a glass of water, and gentely try to push it down. you will see the efect that I m talking about plus, the base of the hackle traps small bubbles of air, that is verry atractive to the fish. Or put the smallest amount of Uv dubbing in the loop with the deer hair If you have allready done this, ignore the post above Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
MarianC 0 Report post Posted November 17, 2010 these ar the flies Tied on a Gamakatsu G-code F22 size 14 and size 16 Hass Hans van Klinken says, use polypropeline yarn, it traps more floating gel Hope you find anything good in this flies One thing, Deer hair is not great for fast waters. Great for trout to, but tied with Pheasant tail fibers, and small cooper wire for ribbing Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Bryan Wright 0 Report post Posted November 17, 2010 Hadn't seen it elsewhere. Where might I see others?? Try here for a set of all-hair flies tied by Sven Ostermann, which I added to Flytier's Page in 2001: http://www.danica.com/flytier/sostermann/sostermann.htm A sample: Cheers, Hans W I really like this one. I love the extended body. Is that deer hair also? Looks very buggy and realistic (in an impressionistic way LOL) Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Hans Weilenmann 0 Report post Posted November 17, 2010 I really like this one. I love the extended body. Is that deer hair also? Looks very buggy and realistic (in an impressionistic way LOL) Bryan, Follow the earlier link, click on the thumbnail and the recipe is there. Cheers, Hans W Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Bryan Wright 0 Report post Posted November 17, 2010 I really like this one. I love the extended body. Is that deer hair also? Looks very buggy and realistic (in an impressionistic way LOL) Bryan, Follow the earlier link, click on the thumbnail and the recipe is there. Cheers, Hans W Bookmarked it thanks for the link! :headbang: Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites